
My religion is one wherein the culture is frequently more obvious than the doctrine, a perpetual point of annoyance and vexation for me. Yet despite my contempt for much of the socially manufactured culture, I have found myself unwilling to turn away; for I am unable to deny core dogma the church is built on. If I left my religion because of issues I take with culture, I’d be in what I consider some rather serious moral difficulty, for I would be denying doctrine that I believe to be true.
I was raised Mormon (LDS). I have chosen to remain as such. Though I know my family's sorrow would be tangible to say the least if I elected to leave the church, I have no doubt that they’d still love and accept me. I am not a Mormon for the sake of my family.
That being the case—my remaining a Mormon out of belief, not love of the culture or social habit—I stick out like red on white. I'm seven years married, not infertile that I know of, and feeling no moral, physical, or intellectual hurry to get pregnant. There are very few of me. And because that’s the case, others of my faith (and even those outside it) feel they have some sort of prerogative to ask.
Whether or not I have kids is none of your business. Despite that, I'm about to address the subject. Why? Why indulge outright nosiness? Simply because people aren't perfect.
In an ideal world, no one would ask When? Why? and Why not? regarding progeny. But this isn't the ideal, and for years those who have no right to seek answers have poked their snouts in between our bedsheets.
I'm not irritated with the politely curious. I'm irritated with the moral ramrods, delving into my choices with the aim to correct direction or lambaste for what they believe are poor choices. People aren't perfect, so in spite of the fact that it's without social propriety, they're going to keep asking and judging on the kid front.
Propriety is a high priority for me, and that being the case, I've been existing in contradiction. For when I've responded to the socially inappropriate questions regarding my reproduction I've given answers designed to make the inquirer feel uneasy. I've felt that they deserve it. That's not in accordance with the inherent Me. Thus I've decided that it's time to work through some more clear and mild talking points on the subject.
•••
I'm not a fan of kids. I have never pined for them. Not ever. I have never envisioned myself as a mom and liked what I saw. I don’t get googly over babies. I don't itch to hold 'em. I don’t yearn to be pregnant. I consider my IUD the best kind of friend.
However, the belief system I subscribe to makes very clear that the job of humanity is to make babies and raise 'em up right. Fortuitously, the time frame on which that is to happen is not designated nor mandated. I have been married to The Husband since September of 2002, and according to the Mormon standard, this means that we've been morally permitted to work on stickin' a bun in my oven for seven years. And within the LDS culture—a culture unfortunately often dislocated from its guiding gospel tenets—under common circumstances, we’d already have one or two miniatures.
But I am not now—nor do I believe I’ll ever be—common. The aberration is not by intention or design. It’s by makeup. My ideas are different. My desires are different. My trials are different. And they always have been.
Granted, every soul skipping, wheeling, and walking upon this planet is given a unique set of things to learn and overcome. No one person will live the exact same life as another. However, within the world I inhabit, a world wherein my religion is a generous dictator of my actions, my dislike of children and simultaneous belief that I ought one day spawn some are a contradiction that could be considered a trial. A unique one.
What makes me divergent from others of my kind—Mormons married for more than just a few years and kidless out of choice (yes, I know more than just one of me)—is that I don't like kids. I've no yen at all to have my own. The other Mormons I know in a similar situation are fans of children, are looking forward to having them, but believe that the time isn't right for them just yet. Not me; for, as a general rule, I don't want much of anything to do with the little ones.
Does this mean I want no part of my niece and nephews? 'Course not. They're my family, and if you've paid any attention at all to my writings you'd know that my family is of supreme importance to me, and I'll gladly mar beyond recognition anyone who desires to do them harm. Jack, Van, Addison, and the two baking within Whit and Cat fit into that special subset of humanity for which I'd do just about anything. Of course I love them. It's a key ingredient of who I am—a reflexive love and tenderness for mi familia.
I have made certain promises throughout my career as a Mormon that, should I heed what I've said I would, mean that I will lend a hand to multiplying and replenishing the earth—adding to bits and pieces of humanity growing denser on this planet. Means I’ll one day have kids.
One day.
This is not that day.
One day is not today.
And, believe it or not, good people—of my faith and otherwise—that is just fine.
Is my dislike for kids a poor reflection on my parents and upbringing? No. I cannot scream that loud enough. I was raised well. I have a strong set of values. I have a number of useful talents my parents cultivated and encouraged. I was raised what I would say is rightly. The way I feel about kids and motherhood is a part of me. It's my own challenge to work through and figure out. For though, throughout the world, it is becoming more common to go kidless by choice, for the most part—religion aside, we inhabit a society where having children is the norm and going without is the deviance.
Clinically, I'm fascinated (and completely grossed out) by gestation and birth. Watching my sister eject her second born was an experience unparalleled in this life so far. But I didn’t cradle her new-to-oxygen son and wish for my own. I never have wished for my own. I’m not sure I ever will.
At this point (a key phrase, for I have iron conviction in the human capacity to change without warning), I believe that when I finally have a kidlet or two it won’t be because I’m baby hungry or because I want so badly to experience motherhood. I believe, like some before me (more than you realize, trust me), I will at last be amenable motherhood because I will feel that, despite my personal distaste for the profession, it's the next step in my eternal progression. I'll put faith in Lord that it's the right thing to do and jump off one hell of a cliff.
While still on the solid ground of a childfree life, I am enjoying myself. Another conviction I hold to securely is the concept that whatever station in life we find ourselves, within it we ought to seek out happiness. I have so much to be happy with in my current stage, and I take advantage of all that I can. I sleep late on weekends. I spend hours learning design programs. I go to yoga when I please. I relish the silence of my home. All this and so much more are benefits I savor and glorify in my life without kids. They are a part of a stage. A stage I'm unsure how long will last. But no matter how long, it's a place to seek enjoyment and recognize unique felicity.
When you read me extolling the many wonders of being without kids, don't make the mistake of thinking that I feel some kind of disdain or sorrow for you who are in the throes of raising. I respect your choices as I'd expect you to respect mine. There are bits of life to love no matter where we're landed, and I plan on living up this present part.
22 comments:
What a glorious post today. This is me giving you a round of applause and a huzzah. I loved the snouts in between the sheets metaphor.
Edric and I were happy with 2 and people kept asking us when we were going to add another that he would start asking them "why do you want to be there when we start trying" We were never asked again. A little abrupt but it was no ones business. I applaud your post and I applaud you! As you can see in my last comment aka "the Tony incident" (Children should only be born when wanted, otherwise you run the risk of killing them) :) .
here's to cliff jumping. One day.
Cheers.
Agency is all apart of the plan, just like children are. You and I have had this conversation so many times. And I don't think you are going to hell. I have rough days with my children, you have rough days with your job. It's all relative. I would rather die than get up and go to work and you would rather die than get up and make oatmeal with raisins and empty the dishwasher. Joy isn't found in one singular place at one singular time. Everyone's learning and growing in life and lots of people forget that there is no written standard. They feel bad for you for not having children, you feel bad for them for judging you with such ignorance.
And hey, if 7 years brings children, you should be on number 3 by now. I am and so should everyone else!
Great post!! This is such a hot topic for me. I have yet to understand why people think it is any of their business if one has kids or how many kids one chooses to have.
I know friends, some family members and even acquaintances over the years have chosen to make comments about the size of our family. After we announced we were having our fourth child the rude questions/comments started to flow. How will you manage to take care of four kids? How will you afford it, do you know how expensive kids are these days? My gosh, Brian works so much you already don't have enough help around the house, how will you manage? Are you crazy? I bit my tongue for quite a while, then I couldn't handle it anymore. I started being rude right back, telling people straight out that it was none of their business how many kids we have. That Brian and I were all grown up and well aware of what we were doing when we decided to have a fourth child.
I would really love to get inside these rude peoples heads to find out what makes them feel the need to spout off at the mouth about something so personal as to how many (if any) children a couple has. It just drives me WILD. Can you tell? I say when it comes to this subject, if you can't say anything nice, then shut your face.
I love this post I have had the same experience just different. My husband wanted a large family and after 6 1/2 years we were finally given one child. During that time I was always asked the dreaded when are you having kids question. At first I tried to explain, this only caused me pain. I then began telling people "Don't you know I can't have kids", this would shut them up. I felt bad being a little rude and in a way lying. Then I realized they were the ones being rude.
You would think now that I have one people would leave me alone. Not the case. I am putting as much effort as I did before with no reward. The worst are my in-laws. With all the struggles we had before you think they would get it. They don't. I need to deal with this issue within myself before it gets ugly at the next family function.
Continue to enjoy the time without children. I often wish I had those days back. I love my son dearly, it is just hard to no longer have "me time"
Ooops! My post was supposed to say my husband and I wanted a large family. Big difference from just my husband wanting a large family.
Rock on, lady. Being without little kids does have its definite advantages, even in the throes of all my pathetic baby longing I see that and I'm grateful for the time I've had. Sleeping in till ten is NOT something I take lightly.
First and foremost my fine frined, YOU are a person of respect. A person who notices the details of most everything and RESPECTS those details. You don't do things lightly or half-assed. So when you say you are not ready for kids or want kids or whatever, I see respect. Respect for child-rearing.
Raising a child is a sacred opportunity. One that shouldn't be taken lightly. YOU get that. Many do not (not that I'm gonna name names... "WINDER!" kidding.)
The sad thing about the culture of Mormons is that since we all exist in the same "family", many assume all of our beliefs are the same. When they are not the same, they want to know why. Maybe it's because those people are scared? If someone else's ideals are different than their own, perhaps they are doing it wrong? Dunno, just a thought. Sadly, many Mormons find comfort in going with the crowd. Sometimes individuality is not accepted or worse, encouraged. I think that's very sad.
Now back to everyone believing their beliefs are the same. Well... they are, to an extent. But there's that whole agency thing that Whitney so fittingly put into the mix. We get to choose how our life goes. God wants that for us. He wants us to make our own decisions and suffer/receive rewards for those consequences.
I believe that was THE PLAN. At least that's the part of THE PLAN that coerced me into signing up via dunkage.
I want to be here because I have chosen to be here. I want the blood, sweat and tears that come with making hard decisions. I don't want to be here because I was given a checklist of things to accomplish. You might think that I'm trying to side-step commandments. Hardly. For keeping commandments is still a choice. When you are forced with the decision of making true to a covenant, you still must decide if that's what you want to do. Every dang day.
Pining for children is not a prerequisite, you know. I never had that deep burning in my bosom for a child. Babies aren't my thing either. When someone has a baby, I rarely ask to hold it.
For the record, we jumped off that cliff before I was ready(but only because Spouse was almost 38!)
Maybe age will do the same for you? Maybe. If not, I'll love you just the same.
That is a fantastic post, by the way. I've read it four times and will prolly read it again before the day is done.
Look at me use your comments to do my own post. Sorry.
I've reread this post several times, and I respect and agree with it whole-heartedly. I also second Rabid's response...it's all about that tricky thing called free-will, and it's certainly part of THE PLAN.
I'm with Rabid here. You have such a respect for life and you are a perfectionist in all that you do, that I can see such a reverence for this subject. I totally respect, and quite surprisingly, relate to your position on this. And you're right, it's none of our business. As long as you're happy, I'm happy.
I'm actually not a fan of kids, though I've got a litter of them. I don't yearn to hold other kids. I hate being pregnant. I actually hated babysitting when I was growing up. I still hate babysitting. The only kids I enjoy are my own and my nieces and nephew, but even then, I am not a fan of watching them. I love alone time. I love quiet. Love it. This has been the biggest adjustment to being a mom. I can say, though, that although being a mom has been super trying for me, but it's also taught me so much. So, for me, it's been a good thing.
Just so you know, though, I think when and if you do become a mom, those little kids are going to be so lucky. You will teach them things that matter and teach them to respect others, to defend what matters and to look at things in a new light. Yep, I think you'll rock at it, like you do everything else.
And also, Mormons are crazy. C'mon, people. Getting married and busting out kids is insane. I'm guilty of it but it doesn't mean I condone it. Who made these dumb "rules"? I have issues with the whole culture, not the gospel...just the culture.
your honesty made me feel like i breathed air for the first time right now!
do you know how many people there must be out there, who ARE just like you, who are AFRAID to say what you have just said?!
good for you! good for you!!!!!
do you know that i never, ever longed for a child? to be a mother? i knew i would be, i never questioned that. i knew that i would quit my career and be a mother. but i never had that longing. i just did it.
and i surprised myself at how much i ended up loving it, and throwing every last shred of effort at the task of mothering. and i was "old" in The Culture....almost 28 when i had my first. and 30 when i had my last. and i only had TWO. another topic along the same lines, ya know?
but here's the dealio.....i know my limits. and i know i don't have what it takes to be the kind of mother i want and need to be, to a brood of children.
but anyhoo......i am going to re-read this post when i go to bed. i'm in the middle of dinner (i guess the children do have to be fed...lol) and want to be able to really digest what you've posted. excellent job!
Bless you for taking on this hornets' nest! I too have never had any desire to leap into the maternal morass, and I relish my child-free life. The Culture has made it pretty painful to be different, yet I can't quite walk away from the truths of the Gospel tenets. It's like swallowing shards of glass when I feel that conversation brewing..."when? why? what's with your timing?"
Thank you for serving up substantial food for thought.
"I'll put faith in the Lord that it's the right thing to do and jump off one hell of a cliff."
This line really struck a cord with me, because this is exactly my mindset when I decide to have another child. One of my trials on this earth is to have loss in this department. I have three living children, two stillborn, and two miscarriages. It is downright terrifying to jump off that cliff. I have to know without a shred of doubt that it's the Lord's will or I just can't do it. When it is His timing and will, He has a way of changing my heart.
Even with three I get the "when are you trying for another?" comments. I was recently asked this question by my child's doctor (who is a Baptist and father of 12). Now, keep in mind, this man is a saint, and I owe my daughter's eyes to him, BUT... he didn't back off at the usual, polite things I say to deflect such comments. I finally had to pull out the big guns. "This is a sensitive area for me. I've already buried two children. I'm grateful for and happy with the three I have." He was apologetic of course. I've learned that you just don't go there. If you are close with someone, and they bring it up, that's one thing. Otherwise, its noneya.
It seems you have it all figured out. Loved the post.
Brava.
What a rather long blog entry in which you justify to the world that you do not need to justify to the world that you will not have children.
I am an inactive member of the LDS Church and when I was last active more than 15+ years ago, I was very conflicted upon seeing so many young, newly married couples spew forth child after child in rapid succession. I couldn't understand how these couples afforded so many children at such a young age, and worse, how they could properly foster their young marriages after introducing children so quickly into the mix (and enjoy sex as SEX, and not in a pro-creative, utilitarian capacity).
These couples got caught up in the culture of what they believed was expected of them, rather than exercising their free agency and will to decide what was best for themselves.
They governed themselves out of fear of God and rebuke from their fellow members and the heirarchy of the Church, in my opinion and observation. It was an all or nothing mentality and no middle ground was ever met or even considered.
I know, because I was like that.
What I witnessed during that time 15 years ago was that most Mormon moms I knew seemed and appeared to be the most guilt-ridden women I had ever run across. They were also the most depressed (and not to mention, frumpy women) partly because they never had time to take care of or put an effort into themselves since their whole being was wrapped up in child producing and child rearing, and goodness knows whatever commandments of which they were afraid of failing.
Now today, imagine what a breath of fresh air it was to run across your blog, and the blogs of many other young, smart, creative, delightful, opinionated, free-willing, beautiful, hip, sassy, stylish, savvy, fashion-forward, forward-thinking, Mormon women of today. You all are so much different than the Mormon women I knew of 15 years ago.
Kudos to you Sparks and the Husband for enjoying your life, sans chillen, as an active Mormon couple, and not feeling guilty or depressed about it. When and if you ever have kids is your own bidness, but in the meantime, enjoy your time between the sheets together, without worrying if you forgot to lock the bedroom door!
Great post Megan - I'm confronted with this question a lot now because that nebulous "everyone" seems to be having a baby except for me. And I'm happy with my decision to not have one at this point in my life - it's just not a priority. Unfortunately, I'm still struggling with a witty response that is direct enough...was recently asked "Aren't you worried about your fertility?" by a man I barely knew and wanted to give him a tight slap.
I'm thinking THE PLAN is an LDS reference but it sounds like something from the Matrix (like "The Oracle")!
Great post. Sorry this is a few days late but I've been without a computer (aka: hell) for a few days.
It's shocking sometimes how dense people can be. Do they not hear the rudeness that just spewed from the hole in their face? Just out of curiousity, (and I hope I'm not sounding dense myself) but does The Spouse have any feelings either way on this? My husband is starting to chomp at the bit for a kiddo, but I blame that on the fact that small things love him. Small animals, small humans, etc... I on the other hand, don't see a baby any time soon. Just wondering if your Spouse has an opinion either way.
P.S. Mormon culture IS vexing. We had the missionaries over for dinner and one of them, poor kid, couldn't wrap his head around the fact that we don't have kids and I fully intend on going to medical school. Ugh. I quote, "...but girls aren't supposed to go on missions. They're supposed to focus on getting married and being mothers"
I don't normally comment when I read your posts because I'm in too much of a hurry to finish before my break is over, but I love reading your posts. You have a great way with words and I know I'm late to this post but I had to comment. This was a great one. I whole heartedly agree with you and I applaud you for reminding people of free agency and eternal progression. My husband and I are in a similar boat. Married 7 1/2 years and no kids -by choice. :) I know (for me) that I'll be a better mother for waiting and gaining the experiences I've had in the mean time. Everyone is different and we should respect everyone's opinions and choices. Thanks Megan for posting this. -Sorry I lurk and don't comment very often. I'll work on not hanging in the shadows.
Post a Comment